Rector argues against ban on new HMOs


Rector Catherine Stihler declined the opportunity to support the current ban on new House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) licenses within the town centre, under questioning from local councillors last night.

Arguing from the student perspective of the long running ‘town versus gown’ debate, Ms Stihler told the St Andrews Community Council that “I do have concerns about the purpose of the HMO ban… it has to be seriously looked at.”

Community Council chairman Howard Greenwell said that Ms Stihler’s invitation to appear in front of the Community Council was at least in part due to comments she had made to the media when appointed Rector last year. She said at the time that one of her priorities was to lobby for an “alleviating (of) the HMO ban”. These comments had concerned the councillors, who wanted to present their opinions to the Rector face to face.

In particular, community councillor Penny Uprichard said that Ms Stihler was “starting at the wrong end.” However, Miss Uprichard went on to express sympathy for the housing issues which students face and told a story of how her relatives had in the past taken in students to live in their homes.

Ms Stihler went on to say that there are “issues of commonality that we can work on,” in particular the dampness found in student properties and its possible health effects.

A HMO ban within the centre of town has existed since June 2011. This means that no new HMO licences will be granted within the town centre.

There have also been further attempts to extend the ban outside of the town centre.

The council also discussed the Rector’s attitude to Raisin Weekend. Mr Greenwell said that the current situation, especially on Raisin Sunday, is “a little bit too rowdy for a lot of people” and explained that in the 1970s, the only drinking that took place was from 6:30pm to 10pm when the pubs were open.

In response, Ms Stihler paid tribute to the work of safety staff from the University and revealed that “I will be out helping this year”, extending the same invite to the community councillors.


  1. Apparently, Penny Uprichard incurred legal costs upwards of 179000 Pounds in 2013 in an attempt to stop the expansion of St Andrews through the proposed development of housing, a business park, a science park, and transport links.

    Ms. Uprichard, everything in the world changes!! Towns and communities evolve; people move in, they move out; new buildings replace old ones. St Andrews will always retain a unique charm as a university town with stunning views of the North Sea. Yet you still think that St Andrews ought to remain the same as it was decades agos This will not happen.

    Stop this nonsense of the HMO ban because it is hurting students and the development of the town. St Andrews may have been an idyllic paradise, a Scottish Hobbiton, but that was (probably?) over half or even a whole century ago.

    If you would like peace and quiet, no students, no international people, no HMOs, and no change, I recommend that you move to a small isolated community in the Highlands, or better yet, St Kilda.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.